Wednesday Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

Trying to rank the discography of a band like Wednesday is a fascinating challenge.

Their blend of searing noise rock, shoegaze atmosphere, and deeply personal Southern storytelling creates a catalog where every album feels essential.

Here, we're taking a deep look at the Wednesday albums ranked, guided first and foremost by fan sentiment. We want to know which records resonate most with the community, helping us uncover what might be considered the best Wednesday albums.

Later, we'll see how this compares to current popularity data.

Ranking Wednesday's albums: The fan favorites

This is how the albums stack up based on community discussions, fan polls, and overall buzz.

We're starting with the most beloved record in their collection.

1. Rat Saw God (2023)

Released in 2023, Rat Saw God is Wednesday's fifth studio album and a monumental release for the band.

The record received widespread critical acclaim, with many praising its powerful and riveting depiction of life in the American South.

Frontwoman Karly Hartzman felt more confident in her singing on this album, a confidence that clearly shines through in the final mix. The band honed a heavier sound that perfectly blends country textures with shoegaze and emo influences.

Key tracks:

• Quarry
• Chosen to Deserve

It's no surprise that Rat Saw God claims the top spot. For many, this album represents the perfect synthesis of everything Wednesday had been building towards.

The storytelling is sharper, the sound is bigger, and the emotional impact is undeniable. It's a modern classic that has resonated deeply with both longtime fans and new listeners.

---

2. Twin Plagues (2021)

Twin Plagues is the band's third studio album, released in 2021 via Orindal Records.

This record saw the band lean further into a dissonant noise pop and shoegaze sound, all while maintaining their indie rock and grunge pop sensibilities.

Critics noted the album's big, loud sound, which often carried a palpable undercurrent of anxiety beneath its complex layers.

Key tracks:

• How Can You Live If You Can’t Love How Can You If You Do
• Cody's Only

Securing the second spot, Twin Plagues is often viewed as the moment Wednesday truly solidified their signature sound.

It's an album that perfectly set the stage for their later success, and its raw energy continues to be a major touchstone for the band's fanbase.

---

3. Mowing the Leaves Instead of Piling 'em Up (2022)

This 2022 release is a covers album, allowing the band to pay homage to their wide-ranging musical influences.

The sound spans country, Americana, and alternative rock, showcasing the band's versatility and deep appreciation for their musical heroes.

Karly Hartzman stated that the band recorded it because they owe so much to their influences, and it was a way to celebrate the music that brought them together.

Key tracks:

• She's Actin' Single (I'm Drinkin Double) [Gary Stewart]
• Perfect (Smashing Pumpkins)

It's always telling when a covers album ranks this highly among fans. It shows a deep connection not just to the band's original work, but to their entire musical identity.

Listeners clearly appreciate hearing Wednesday put their unique spin on songs from artists like Gary Stewart and The Smashing Pumpkins, making it a beloved, if unconventional, entry.

---

4. I Was Trying to Describe You to Someone (2020)

The band's second studio album, released in 2020, marked a key point in their evolution. This was the record where the full band lineup began to take shape.

It laid much of the groundwork for their acclaimed mixture of shoegaze and country rock. The album was born from Hartzman's desire to explore a sound that departed from some of her previous projects.

Key tracks:

• November
• Fate Is…

For longtime followers, I Was Trying to Describe You to Someone is a crucial part of the Wednesday story.

While it may not have the polish of their later work, it contains the raw DNA of their sound and holds a special place for those who have followed their journey from the beginning.

---

5. Bleeds (2025)

Set for release in September 2025, Bleeds is the band's sixth studio album and the follow-up to their acclaimed 2023 record.

Karly Hartzman described it as the quintessential "Wednesday Creek Rock" record, representing the sound the band was always meant to have.

Though not a "dark record," it embraces a "southern gothic attitude" that is a little bit scary but has a heart of gold underneath.

Key tracks:

• Reality TV Argument Bleeds
• Townies

As a forthcoming album, Bleeds naturally lands lower in a ranking based on existing sentiment. Its position reflects anticipation rather than established history.

However, based on the strength of early singles and the band's current trajectory, there's immense excitement for where this record will ultimately stand in their discography.

---

Picked your top Wednesday classic? Check out Wednesday's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.

---

Wednesday albums: A look at popularity data

While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.

This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.

Below is a ranking of Wednesday's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.

Popularity Rank	Album Title	Release Year
1	Mowing the Leaves Instead of Piling 'em Up	2022
2	Rat Saw God	2023
3	Twin Plagues	2021
4	I Was Trying to Describe You to Someone	2020
5	Bleeds	2025

Quick FAQs about Wednesday's albums

Q: What inspired the sound of Rat Saw God?

A: The album was heavily influenced by a blend of emo, shoegaze, and country. Karly Hartzman specifically drew inspiration from artists like Lucinda Williams, Tom T. Hall, and the Drive-By Truckers.

Q: Who created the album art for Rat Saw God?

A: The distinctive album cover is a six-by-six foot oil painting created by the band's former bassist, Margo Schultz.

---

So, there is our journey through Wednesday's albums ranked by the fans.

Fan sentiment and popularity data both offer valuable perspectives on this incredible discography.

Ultimately, the best Wednesday album is the one that connects with you the most. Each record is a powerful, distinct chapter in their story.

What does your ranking look like?