The Lumineers Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)
Stepping into the heartfelt world of The Lumineers means exploring a discography rich with stories.
It's a journey through foot-stomping anthems and tender ballads. But how do their albums stack up against each other in the eyes of the fans?
Today, we're diving into The Lumineers albums ranked, primarily by the voices that matter most: the listeners. We'll see which records resonate deepest. We'll also glance at what current engagement data suggests about the best The Lumineers albums. Let's begin this musical exploration.
Ranking The Lumineers' albums: The fan favorites
Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.
We're starting with the most beloved.
1. The Lumineers (2012)
This self-titled debut marked the grand arrival of The Lumineers on the music scene.
Released in April 2012, it quickly captured widespread attention and acclaim.
The album featured massive hit singles that became global anthems. Songs like "Ho Hey" and "Stubborn Love" were inescapable.
It achieved significant chart success, impressively peaking at number 2 on the Billboard 200.
Key tracks:
- Ho Hey
- Stubborn Love
Crowning our fan-voted list, The Lumineers clearly holds a special place in the hearts of the fanbase.
Its raw authenticity and instantly memorable melodies cemented its status as a modern folk-rock classic for many listeners.
2. Cleopatra (2016)
Cleopatra served as The Lumineers' much-anticipated second album.
Released in April 2016, it built upon their signature folk-rock foundation with new depth.
The record is known for its character-driven songs and rich, poignant storytelling.
It achieved widespread success, even topping the Billboard 200 chart and resonating globally.
Key tracks:
- Where The Skies Are Blue
- White Lie
Securing the second spot, Cleopatra is often praised by fans for its lyrical depth and emotional narratives.
Many listeners connect deeply with its character studies and the band's evolving musical landscape on this release.
3. Automatic (2025)
Automatic marks the upcoming fifth studio effort from The Lumineers.
It is slated for a February 2025 release. The band reunites with producer David Baron for this project.
This album will continue their musical journey, following up 2022's BRIGHTSIDE.
The band recorded this collection in Woodstock. They aim to explore some of the absurdities of the modern world.
Key tracks:
- Same Old Song
- Asshole
Even ahead of its full release, Automatic is already generating significant buzz among devoted followers.
Early singles and album announcements hint at a thoughtful exploration of contemporary themes, greatly exciting the fanbase.
4. III (2019)
III stands as The Lumineers' ambitious third studio album.
Released in September 2019, this project took a unique conceptual approach to its music and themes.
The album's narrative was visually complemented by an accompanying feature-length film directed by Kevin Phillips.
It's structured in three distinct chapters. These delve into the story of the fictional Sparks family and tackle themes of addiction.
Key tracks:
- Gloria
- Salt And The Sea
The conceptual depth of III clearly resonates with a significant portion of The Lumineers' audience.
Its raw storytelling and the accompanying visual narrative are often highlighted by fans as particularly compelling aspects of the work.
5. BRIGHTSIDE (2022)
BRIGHTSIDE is the fourth studio album from The Lumineers, presented with its title stylized in all caps.
It arrived in January 2022, offering a collection of new tracks to their eager listeners.
Long-time collaborators Simone Felice and David Baron handled the primary production duties for this album.
Singles like the title track "BRIGHTSIDE" and "A.M. RADIO" paved the way for its anticipated release.
Key tracks:
- A.M. RADIO
- WHERE WE ARE
While still appreciated by many, BRIGHTSIDE rounds out this segment of our fan-based ranking.
Fans often find its optimistic tones and familiar sound comforting. However, it might sit differently for some compared to their earlier, perhaps more raw, releases.
The Lumineers albums: A look at popularity data
While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.
This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens entirely.
Below is a ranking of The Lumineers' albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement across various platforms.
| Popularity Rank | Album Title | Release Year |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | The Lumineers | 2012 |
| 2 | Automatic | 2025 |
| 3 | III | 2019 |
| 4 | Cleopatra | 2016 |
| 5 | BRIGHTSIDE | 2022 |
Quick FAQs about The Lumineers's albums
Q: What inspired the cover art for The Lumineers' debut album?
A: The cover art for The Lumineers is quite personal. It features a childhood photograph of lead singer Wesley Schultz's mother and his grandmother.
Q: How did The Lumineers' debut album perform commercially?
A: Their debut album was a significant commercial success. It reached the impressive number 2 spot on the Billboard 200 chart, largely propelled by its hit singles.
So, we've journeyed through The Lumineers albums ranked by the fans.
It's clear each record holds unique memories and meanings for listeners.
The "best" The Lumineers album is always a matter of personal taste and connection. Perhaps it's the one that soundtracked a pivotal moment in your life.
What does your personal ranking of The Lumineers' albums look like? Which songs or albums mean the most to you?