Sabrina Carpenter Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)
Sabrina Carpenter's discography is a journey filled with evolving sounds and heartfelt narratives. For fans, a frequent and passionate topic of conversation is often: which of her albums stand out as the most definitive or beloved?
We're exploring the Sabrina Carpenter albums ranked, guided primarily by the voices of the fans – the community discussions and the sentiment that surrounds each release. This offers a unique perspective on what many consider the best Sabrina Carpenter albums.
Further on, we'll also examine how these albums are performing according to current popularity metrics. Join us as we delve into this fascinating look at Sabrina Carpenter's musical evolution and the albums that have shaped her career!
Ranking Sabrina Carpenter's albums: The fan favorites
Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz, starting with the most beloved.
Short n' Sweet (2024)
Sabrina Carpenter's sixth studio album, Short n' Sweet, quickly made a splash upon its release in August 2024.
Primarily a pop and bubblegum record, it also weaves in country, folk, disco, rock, and R&B influences. The album explores Carpenter's perspectives on modern dating and love, with a title referencing her shorter, impactful relationships and her stature.
Carpenter described it as her second "big girl" album, where she felt complete creative control, following emails i can't send.
The album achieved massive commercial success, driven by hit singles like "Espresso" and "Please Please Please." It topped charts in numerous countries and garnered critical acclaim, with reviewers praising its confident lyrics and enjoyable sound. It also received multiple Grammy nominations, winning Best Pop Vocal Album.
Key Tracks:
- Taste
- Espresso
- Please Please Please
Securing the top position in our fan-driven ranking, Short n' Sweet makes a profound connection with listeners. Fans often praise its confident lyrics and incredibly enjoyable sound.
Eyes Wide Open (2015)
Eyes Wide Open marked Sabrina Carpenter's debut studio album, released in April 2015.
This album, which includes tracks from her debut EP Can't Blame a Girl for Trying, showcases a folk-pop and teen pop sound with acoustic and country influences.
Thematically, Eyes Wide Open delves into Carpenter's personal experiences, friendships, love, and the typical challenges of teenage life. Its production is characterized by guitars, piano, drums, and keyboards.
The album received positive reviews and debuted at number 43 on the US Billboard 200. It was supported by singles "We'll Be the Stars" and the title track "Eyes Wide Open."
Key Tracks:
- Can't Blame a Girl for Trying
- Eyes Wide Open
Ranked at number 2 by fans, Eyes Wide Open holds a special place for many. Its heartfelt storytelling and relatable themes are frequently highlighted as reasons for its appeal.
emails i can't send (2022)
Released in July 2022, emails i can't send is Sabrina Carpenter's fifth studio album and her first with Island Records.
This record is primarily a pop and folk-pop exploration, with elements of alternative pop, electropop, and bedroom pop. The central theme revolves around storytelling based on emails and messages Carpenter wrote but never sent, offering an intimate glimpse into her thoughts.
The album spawned several singles, including "Skinny Dipping," "Fast Times," "Vicious," "Because I Liked a Boy," and the viral hit "Nonsense." A deluxe edition, emails i can't send fwd:, followed in 2023 featuring the popular track "Feather."
Critically, the album was generally well-received and appeared on best-of-2022 lists by publications like Rolling Stone and Billboard, lauded for its vulnerability and mature songwriting.
Key Tracks:
- Nonsense
- because i liked a boy
Coming in at number 3 in our fan ranking, emails i can't send strikes a chord with its audience. The album is widely admired for its vulnerable storytelling and raw honesty.
EVOLution (2016)
EVOLution, Sabrina Carpenter's second studio album, arrived in October 2016.
This album marked a significant shift in sound for Carpenter, moving away from the folk-pop of her debut towards a more dance-pop-oriented style. Recording for the project began in 2015, shortly after her first album's release.
The album was met with positive reviews from music critics, who often noted Carpenter's growth and maturity. It debuted at number 28 on the US Billboard 200, her highest-charting album at the time.
Singles like "On Purpose" and the popular "Thumbs" helped promote the album, showcasing its new sonic direction.
Key Tracks:
- Thumbs
- On Purpose
Positioned at number 4 according to fan sentiment, EVOLution is a significant album for many. Listeners often commend its confident transition into a mature dance-pop sound.
Singular Act II (2019)
Released in July 2019, Singular: Act II served as the sequel to Sabrina Carpenter's 2018 album, Singular: Act I.
This fourth studio album, and her final with Hollywood Records, continued to explore pop, R&B, and dance genres. However, Act II delved into more personal topics, including anxiety and self-reflection, offering a more vulnerable side compared to its predecessor.
Carpenter had originally intended a single album titled Singular but decided to split it due to differing lyrical content between the two parts.
The album was supported by promotional singles such as "Pushing 20," "Exhale," and "In My Bed," and featured a guest appearance from Saweetie. It received generally positive reviews, with critics noting its mature themes and Carpenter's evolving artistry.
Key Tracks:
- Looking at Me
- Exhale
Occupying the 5th spot in this fan-based ranking, Singular Act II connects with fans on a personal level. It’s particularly noted for its exploration of anxiety and introspective themes.
Singular Act I (2018)
Singular: Act I, Sabrina Carpenter's third studio album, was released in November 2018.
This album marked a distinct dance-pop direction and was themed around self-empowerment. Notably, it was the first project where Carpenter co-wrote every song, showcasing her growing involvement in the creative process.
Work on the album began shortly after her 2016 release, EVOLution. Singular: Act I was envisioned as the first half of a two-part project, followed by Singular: Act II in 2019.
The album was well-received by critics and featured singles like "Almost Love" and "Sue Me." It debuted at number 103 on the US Billboard 200 and was supported by the Singular Tour.
Key Tracks:
- Sue Me
- Paris
At number 6 in the fan favorites list, Singular Act I is appreciated by many. Its empowering anthems and strong sense of self are often cited as its standout qualities.
emails i can’t send fwd: (2023)
emails i can’t send fwd: is the deluxe edition of Sabrina Carpenter's fifth studio album, emails i can't send, released in March 2023.
This expanded version builds upon the original album's themes of vulnerable storytelling, primarily rooted in pop and folk-pop with various other influences. It includes additional tracks that further explore the raw, unfiltered thoughts Carpenter expressed in the initial release.
The original album, released in 2022, marked a significant chapter for Carpenter with Island Records. The deluxe edition added new fan-favorite songs, most notably the hit single "Feather."
Like its predecessor, emails i can’t send fwd: was supported by the ongoing success of singles from the original album and extensive touring, solidifying this era as a pivotal moment in Carpenter's career.
Key Tracks:
- Feather
- opposite
Rounding out the fan favorites at number 7, emails i can’t send fwd: continues to engage listeners. The deluxe edition is praised for offering an expanded collection of vulnerable and relatable tracks.
Sabrina Carpenter albums: A look at popularity data
While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle on an artist's discography.
Below is a ranking of Sabrina Carpenter's albums based on their popularity scores from available data, reflecting which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.
| Popularity Rank | Album Title | Release Year |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Short n' Sweet | 2024 |
| 2 | emails i can't send | 2022 |
| 3 | emails i can’t send fwd: | 2023 |
| 4 | Singular Act II | 2019 |
| 5 | EVOLution | 2016 |
| 6 | Singular Act I | 2018 |
| 7 | Eyes Wide Open | 2015 |
Quick FAQs about Sabrina Carpenter's albums
Q: What makes Short n' Sweet stand out in Sabrina Carpenter's discography?
A: Short n' Sweet is noted for its confident lyrics, enjoyable pop and bubblegum sound with diverse influences, and themes exploring modern dating. It also marked a period of significant commercial success and creative control for Carpenter, earning critical acclaim and awards.
Q: What were the major singles from Short n' Sweet?
A: The album was propelled by highly successful singles "Espresso" and "Please Please Please," both topping global charts. "Taste" was released alongside the album, and "Bed Chem" followed as another single, contributing to its widespread popularity.
So there you have it – a comprehensive look at Sabrina Carpenter's albums, ranked through the lens of devoted fan discussions and complemented by current popularity data.
While these rankings offer valuable perspectives, the "best" Sabrina Carpenter album is often a deeply personal choice, tied to the individual memories and feelings her music evokes. Each release represents a unique era in her artistic journey and for her listeners.
What does your personal ranking of Sabrina Carpenter's albums look like? Which one holds the top spot for you, and why?