Of Monsters and Men Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)
Few bands have a sound as instantly recognizable as Of Monsters and Men. Their unique blend of Icelandic folk, soaring anthems, and narrative lyricism creates a world all its own.
Looking back at their discography invites a common debate among listeners. Which release stands as their most defining work?
Here, we explore the Of Monsters and Men albums ranked according to the fans. We're using community sentiment as our primary guide to determine what many consider the best Of Monsters and Men album.
We'll also see how popularity data tells a slightly different story.
Ranking Of Monsters and Men's albums: The fan favorites
Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.
We're starting with the most beloved.
1. My Head Is An Animal (2012)

This is the debut studio album that introduced the world to the Icelandic indie folk band.
Originally released in Iceland in 2011, its international release came in 2012 after the massive success of its lead single, "Little Talks". That track propelled the band to global recognition and a deal with Universal Music Group.
The album's title is famously taken from the second line of the opening song, "Dirty Paws".
Key tracks:
- Little Talks
- Dirty Paws
It's no surprise that My Head Is An Animal holds the top spot for fans. Debut albums often capture a lightning-in-a-bottle energy, and this record is a perfect example.
This is the album that defined their sound and provided the foundation for everything that followed. For countless listeners, it was their entry point into the band's magical, story-filled world.
2. Beneath The Skin (2015)

Beneath The Skin is the band's second studio album, released in the summer of 2015.
It achieved significant commercial success, debuting at number three on the US Billboard 200. This made it the band's highest-charting album in the country.
The album's title comes from a lyric in the song "Human": "Plants awoke and they slowly grow beneath the skin."
Key tracks:
- Crystals
- Slow Life
Securing the second spot, Beneath The Skin is seen by many fans as a powerful and mature evolution of the band's sound.
It carries a slightly darker and more introspective tone than its predecessor, a depth that clearly resonated with listeners and solidified their emotional connection to the band's music.
3. FEVER DREAM (2019)

The band's third studio album, FEVER DREAM, was released in July 2019.
It was co-produced by the band and Rich Costey, and was introduced by the driving lead single "Alligator".
The record marked a notable shift in their creative process, with Nanna Bryndís Hilmarsdóttir exploring new sounds on a laptop rather than a traditional acoustic guitar.
Key tracks:
- Alligator
- Wild Roses
While third in the fan ranking, FEVER DREAM holds a special place as the band's most sonically adventurous album.
Its brighter, poppier textures and electronic influences represented a bold step forward. This evolution may have divided some longtime listeners, but it also showcased the band's versatility and willingness to explore new territory.
Picked your top Of Monsters and Men classic? Check out Of Monsters and Men's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.
Of Monsters and Men albums: A look at popularity data
Support Our Work
Listen great music, try 30 days of Amazon Music Unlimited on us. You get access to more than 100 million songs, we get a small kickback too.
Claim Your Free MonthWhile fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.
This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.
Below is a ranking of Of Monsters and Men's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.
Popularity Rank | Album Title | Release Year |
---|---|---|
1 | My Head Is An Animal | 2012 |
2 | FEVER DREAM | 2019 |
3 | Beneath The Skin | 2015 |
Quick FAQs about Of Monsters and Men's albums
Q: Where does the title My Head Is An Animal come from?
A: The title is taken directly from the second line of the album's opening track, "Dirty Paws".
Q: What is the story behind the cover art for My Head Is An Animal?
A: The image on the international release is a photograph taken by guitarist Brynjar's grandfather of a friend. The band's drummer, Arnar, added the coloring to the original black and white photo.
That completes our journey through Of Monsters and Men's albums ranked by fans and data.
The enduring love for their debut is clear, but every album represents a vital part of their musical story.
The "best" Of Monsters and Men album is always the one that connects with you the most. Each record offers a different reason to fall in love with their sound.
How would you rank their albums?