Of Mice & Men Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

Diving into the discography of Of Mice & Men is a journey through modern metalcore.

From their raw beginnings to their more polished, arena-ready sound, each album tells a story. But which one resonates the most with the people who matter most? The fans.

We're looking at all Of Mice & Men albums ranked, guided by fan sentiment and community discussion. This gives us a real sense of what many consider the best Of Mice & Men album.

Later, we’ll check out how popularity data tells a different story.

Ranking Of Mice & Men's albums: The fan favorites

Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.

We're starting with the most beloved.

1. Of Mice & Men (2010)

The band's self-titled debut album hit the scene in early 2010.

Recorded with producer Joey Sturgis, this record established the raw, aggressive sound that first captured fans' attention.

It was a powerful statement of intent. The album quickly gained traction after a demo was sent to Rise Records, leading to the band's signing.

Key tracks:

• Second & Sebring
• This One's for You

Taking the top spot, the debut album holds a special place for many listeners. It's the sound of a band bursting with hunger and aggression.

For longtime fans, this record is pure nostalgia. It represents the foundation of everything that came after.

2. The Flood (2011)

Released in 2011, `The Flood` was the band's sophomore effort.

It marked the return of founding vocalist Austin Carlile. The album built upon their debut's sound with tracks like "Still YDG'N" and "Purified" leading the charge.

A deluxe reissue followed in 2012, adding four new songs to the already powerful tracklist.

Key tracks:

• When You Can't Sleep at Night
• O.G. Loko

As the fan-favorite runner-up, `The Flood` is often seen as the perfection of the band's early style.

It captured the raw energy of the debut but with tighter songwriting and more memorable hooks, cementing its place as an essential OM&M record.

3. Echo (2021)

`Echo` arrived in 2021 as the band's seventh studio album.

It uniquely compiled three EPs released throughout the year: `Timeless`, `Bloom`, and `Ad Infinitum`.

This record was self-produced by the band during the pandemic, showcasing their ability to adapt and create remotely. It was also their first full-length with SharpTone Records.

Key tracks:

• Obsolete
• Pulling Teeth

The high ranking for `Echo` shows strong fan appreciation for the band's modern era.

Its consistent release schedule throughout the year kept fans engaged, and the final collection felt both cohesive and powerful.

4. Restoring Force (2014)

`Restoring Force` marked a significant evolution for Of Mice & Men.

It was the first album to feature bassist and clean vocalist Aaron Pauley, who brought a new dynamic to their sound.

Produced by David Bendeth, the record moved towards a more nu-metal and hard rock-influenced style, broadening their appeal.

Key tracks:

• Would You Still Be There
• Bones Exposed

This album is well-regarded by fans who appreciated the band's willingness to grow.

The combination of Carlile's screams and Pauley's melodic vocals created a powerful contrast that defined a new chapter for the group.

5. Defy (2018)

Released in 2018, `Defy` was a crucial album for Of Mice & Men.

It was their first record with Aaron Pauley handling all lead vocals, following the departure of Austin Carlile.

Produced by Howard Benson, the album proved the band could continue as a powerful four-piece, blending heavy riffs with soaring choruses.

Key tracks:

• Unbreakable
• Back To Me

Fans see `Defy` as a statement of resilience. It answered the big question of what the band would sound like moving forward.

Its solid standing shows that the fanbase embraced this new configuration and Pauley's role as the frontman.

6. EARTHANDSKY (2019)

`EARTHANDSKY` followed `Defy` in 2019.

Working with producer Josh Wilbur, the band aimed for a heavier sound on this album compared to its predecessor.

It blended crushing instrumentation with melodic sensibilities, serving as their final album with Rise Records.

Key tracks:

• Taste of Regret
• Earth & Sky

This record is appreciated by fans who were eager for a return to a more aggressive style.

While it may not rank as high as the classic albums, `EARTHANDSKY` is recognized as a strong and focused effort from the modern lineup.

7. Cold World (2016)

The band's fourth album, `Cold World`, was released in 2016.

It continued the sonic direction explored on `Restoring Force`, once again with producer David Bendeth at the helm.

Notably, this was the final album to feature founding vocalist Austin Carlile before his departure due to ongoing health issues.

Key tracks:

• Pain
• Real

`Cold World` is often viewed as a transitional and somewhat divisive record among fans.

While it contains some standout tracks, its overall reception was more mixed, landing it lower in the fan-driven ranking.

8. Tether (2023)

`Tether` is the band's eighth and most recent studio album, released in 2023.

Marking another milestone, this entire album was self-produced by the band members themselves.

The record showcases a mature and confident version of Of Mice & Men, with the band taking full creative control over their sound.

Key tracks:

• Castaway
• Warpaint

As the newest release, `Tether` is still finding its long-term place in the discography for many fans.

Its position here reflects that it is still fresh, though the band's decision to self-produce was praised by listeners who value their artistic growth.

Picked your top Of Mice & Men classic? Check out Of Mice & Men's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.

Of Mice & Men albums: A look at popularity data

While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.

This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.

Below is a ranking of Of Mice & Men's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.

Quick FAQs about Of Mice & Men's albums

Q: Who produced the first Of Mice & Men album?

A: The band's self-titled debut album was recorded at Foundation Studios with producer Joey Sturgis.

Q: When was the debut album by Of Mice & Men released?

A: Their first album was officially released on March 9, 2010, though it was originally scheduled for a February release.

So there you have it – a look at Of Mice & Men's albums ranked.

We've seen how fan passion crowns the early records, while current data shows the lasting power of key releases across their career.

Ultimately, the "best" Of Mice & Men album is the one that connects with you personally.

What does your ranking look like? Let us know which album stands at the top of your list.