I See Stars Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

Few bands have navigated the intersection of metalcore and electronic music quite like I See Stars.

Their discography is a journey through evolving sounds, from raw electronicore beginnings to more refined, atmospheric productions.

This creates a healthy debate among listeners. We're exploring the full list of I See Stars albums ranked, using fan sentiment as our primary guide to find what many consider the best I See Stars album. We'll also see how popularity data stacks up.

Ranking I See Stars's albums: The fan favorites

Here's how the albums stack up based on fan sentiment, community discussions, and overall buzz.

We're starting with the most beloved.

1. New Demons (2013)

Image from article: I See Stars Albums Ranked: Fan Favorites (2025)

Released in 2013, New Demons represents a significant progression for the band.

The album leaned further into a prominent EDM sound while giving Zach Johnson a larger vocal role.

It also stands as the final record to feature Johnson and rhythm guitarist Jimmy Gregerson, marking the end of an era for the group's lineup.

Key tracks:

Murder Mitten
Ten Thousand Feet

It's no surprise that New Demons tops the fan ranking. This album is often hailed as the perfect synthesis of the band's heavy and electronic elements.

For many listeners, it's the definitive I See Stars experience, capturing a raw energy that continues to resonate deeply.

2. Treehouse (2016)

Treehouse arrived in 2016 as the band's fifth studio album.

It was the first release after the departure of vocalist Zach Johnson and guitarist Jimmy Gregerson.

This lineup change resulted in a noticeable shift in their sound, with production handled by a team including Erik Ron and David Bendeth.

Key tracks:

Running With Scissors
Calm Snow

Landing at the second spot, Treehouse is celebrated for its maturity and atmospheric depth.

Fans appreciate the band's willingness to evolve, embracing a new direction while retaining the core emotion that defines their music.

3. Digital Renegade (2012)

Digital Renegade, released in 2012, marked a notable turn towards a heavier, more aggressive metalcore sound.

The album featured stronger use of electronics and synthesizers, with guest vocals from Danny Worsnop of Asking Alexandria and Cassadee Pope.

It became their most commercially successful album at the time, reaching number 45 on the Billboard 200.

Key tracks:

Filth Friends Unite
Endless Sky

As a fan favorite, Digital Renegade is remembered for its raw power and punchy production.

It's the album that many feel solidified their heavy credentials, proving they could deliver intense breakdowns alongside catchy electronic hooks.

4. 3-D (2009)

The band's debut album, 3-D, was released in 2009 when all the members were under the age of 20.

It introduced their signature electronicore sound to the world, debuting at number 176 on the Billboard 200.

The record included re-recorded versions of early demos and songs from their first EP, establishing the foundation for their career.

Key tracks:

The Common Hours
What This Means To Me

3-D holds a special place for longtime fans as the starting point of the journey.

While their sound would become more polished later, the youthful energy and ambition on this record are undeniable and still cherished.

5. The End Of The World Party (2011)

The End Of The World Party is the second studio album from I See Stars, released in 2011.

This album continued to build on the electronicore foundation of their debut, refining their blend of pop-infused hooks, synthesizers, and metalcore breakdowns.

Key tracks:

The End Of The World Party
Over It

This album often finds itself in the middle of fan rankings. It's a solid entry that bridges the gap between their raw debut and the more aggressive Digital Renegade.

It contains some classic tracks but is sometimes seen as a transitional record in their broader discography.

6. Phases (2015)

Released in 2015, Phases is a unique project in the band's catalog.

The album features "raw and unplugged" acoustic versions of previously recorded songs, along with a few covers.

It strips away the electronics and screaming, focusing instead on acoustic guitars, piano, and strings to showcase the band's melodic songwriting.

Key tracks:

Youth
Murder Mitten

While appreciated for its artistic ambition, Phases is often viewed by fans as a side project rather than a core studio release.

Its lower ranking reflects a preference for the band's signature high-energy sound, though the reimagined tracks are widely respected.

7. Renegades Forever (2013)

Renegades Forever is a mixtape that collects B-sides, remixes, and demos from the Digital Renegade era.

The release served as a bridge between Digital Renegade and their next full-length album, New Demons.

It offered fans a deeper look into the creative process and featured collaborations with artists like Frank Palmeri of Emmure.

Key tracks:

Underneath Every Smile (Acoustic Version)
The Hardest Mistakes (Popkong Mix)

As a collection of remixes and B-sides, Renegades Forever is naturally ranked lower than the main studio albums.

Fans see it as a companion piece rather than a standalone statement, making it more of a deep cut for dedicated listeners.

8. THE WHEEL (2025)

After a long hiatus, I See Stars returned with their sixth studio album, THE WHEEL.

This album marks their first full-length release in nearly a decade, continuing with the four-piece lineup established on Treehouse.

The record was highly anticipated, signaling a new chapter for the band while reconnecting with their dedicated fanbase.

Key tracks:

carry on for you
Lost It

As the newest entry, THE WHEEL is still finding its long-term place in the band's discography.

Its current ranking reflects that it's a fresh release, and fan consensus is still forming compared to the established classics that have had years to cement their legacy.

Picked your top I See Stars classic? Check out I See Stars's discography on their Roll The Record Artist hub.

I See Stars albums: A look at popularity data

Support Our Work

Listen great music, try 30 days of Amazon Music Unlimited on us. You get access to more than 100 million songs, we get a small kickback too.

Claim Your Free Month

While fan sentiment paints a rich picture, current popularity data can offer another interesting angle.

This looks at an artist's discography through a different lens.

Below is a ranking of I See Stars's albums based on their popularity scores from available data. This reflects which releases are currently seeing significant engagement.

Popularity Rank	Album Title	Release Year
1	Treehouse	2016
2	THE WHEEL	2025
3	New Demons	2013
4	Digital Renegade	2012
5	3-D	2009
6	Phases	2015
7	The End Of The World Party	2011
8	Renegades Forever	2013

Quick FAQs about I See Stars's albums

Q: Which lineup of I See Stars recorded the fan-favorite album New Demons?

A: New Demons was the final album to feature the lineup with unclean vocalist and keyboardist Zach Johnson and rhythm guitarist Jimmy Gregerson before they parted ways with the band in 2015.

Q: What makes the sound on New Demons stand out?

A: The album is known for progressing the band's sound by incorporating a much more prominent EDM influence. It also gave Zach Johnson a significantly larger vocal role compared to previous records.

So there it is, a deep look at the I See Stars albums ranked by the fans.

Both fan consensus and popularity data show which albums have made the biggest impact.

But the best I See Stars album is always the one that connects with you the most. Each record offers something different in their impressive musical evolution.

What does your ranking look like?